This story from National Underwriter about the Fifth Circuit's Leonard v. Nationwide decision has some interesting quotes from Brian Martin, policy director for Rep. Gene Taylor, D-Miss., and because when Martin speaks on insurance matters it announces the start of the Silly Season, this stuff is in serious need of an industrial-strength Fisking. I will get to that by and by, but first I need to correct some misunderstandings in one of first paragraphs of the story. Here is the paragraph: The anti-concurrent causation clause is used to override a damage claim from a covered cause such as wind when an event such as flood, which is excluded in the policy language, occurs in the same time period.
A couple things (those of you who have heard all this before can skip down to the Fisking):I.
Related Headlines
- Nationwide v. Leonard: Fifth Circuit upholds anti-concurrent cause provision as unambiguousposted 58 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- More on Northrop Grumman v. Factory Mutualposted 58 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- Fifth Circuit hears arguments in Leonard v. Nationwide Katrina appealposted 62 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- Is anti-concurrent cause language 'unethical'?posted 54 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- Landry v. Citizens Property: Louisiana Court of Appeals sows confusion, messes up causation analysis in Hurricane Rita cposted 58 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
-
Colorado Court of Appeals: anti-concurrent cause provision bars coverage where covered snow combined with uncovereposted 10 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- Initial impressions on Fifth Circuit's decision in In Re Katrina Canal Breaches Litigationposted 62 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- California U.S. District Court says Katrina storm surge is not excluded by excess policy's flood exclusionposted 59 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
-
First party property causation, New England style
posted 30 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog
- A last word this week on In Re Katrina Canal Breaches Litigationposted 62 weeks ago on Insurance Coverage Blog